Knee-deep in Black-eyed Susans

Sweet black-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia subtomentosa)

If you are a Midwestern gardener, you may be knee-deep in the many rudbeckias that are blooming right now, a not unpleasant experience. Black-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia hirta) have been blooming for some weeks already, but now brown-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia triloba) and sweet black-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia subtomentosa) are getting into the full swing of things. Not all rudbeckias are created equal, and the latter two species are my favorites.  The garden center favorite Rudbeckia ‘Goldsturm’ always seems a bit stiff to me, so as popular as it is, it’s not on my list of favorites. For sheer cuteness, the brown-eyed Susans can’t be beat–they come in tall nosegays of chubby little flowers. Towards the end of the summer, they will get a bit withered and rusty, especially if there has been drought, but they can be yanked out. My all-time favorite rudbeckia is the sweet black-eyed Susan, which is tallish–about 3-1/2 to 4 ft. tall–graceful in habit, and has very clean foliage. Later in the summer the gracefulness might segue into floppiness, but that’s when I swoop in and pick gigantic bouquets of them, and then cut them back. Both of the species self-seed somewhat, and if you want total garden control, they are not for you. Between the two species, if I had to make a choice, I would opt for the sweet black-eyed Susan because of its very clean

Brown-eyed Susans (Rudbeckia triloba)

foliage. Rudbeckias tend to be subject to molds, mildews, and leaf-spot diseases, but the sweet black-eyed Susan stays clean. For information about these diseases, the University of Illinois Extension Service has a website with  info about the various diseases and their (chemical) control. Here’s the address: But that’s why I like the sweet black-eyed Susans–no chemical control is needed. Sometimes sweet black-eyed Susans are called sweet coneflowers. This arises from the time when coneflowers and rudbeckias were lumped together in the same genus. But now purple coneflowers have been lasooed into their own genus (Echinacea) and if something is in Rudbeckia it’s not a coneflower. Or something like that. (In the interest of science, and wondering why this plant is called “sweet,” I have just gone out and nibbled on a leaf–it tasted like an old rubber tire. Oh, well.)

Sometimes New England Asters and various goldenrods are recommended as companions to plant with black-eyed Susans. These can be terrible self-seeders, though, and here is a situation where I would go for hybrids, which are more well-behaved. In particular, some of the hybrid goldenrods are just gorgeous.

Happy gardening!

7 thoughts on “Knee-deep in Black-eyed Susans

  1. Fran,
    Being in the Midwest, I of course planted Black-eyed Susans, but after about 4 years, they all died off. I believe perhaps my yard is too shady, but I so love these wonderfully colorful flowers! I wish I could grow some, but alas, I must just enjoy them from afar in others’ gardens. Yours look beautiful with your daylilies and phlox (and kitties?).

    1. Since much of my yard is in shade, I know the frustration, but I have also found that shade has it’s charms. Still, there are times when I yearn for zinnias and day-glo marigolds!

  2. I have about 6 or 7 Black-eyed Susans (from one about 5 years ago) and they’re all in part shade and bloom. In fact, one is hiding behind a big viburnum and a hydrangea and it’s blooming. Sue, I wonder if something got them in the 4th year? You can’t hardly kill these things, but I guess a bug or cat might. : ( Maybe you could try again!

    Fran, you worry me with your plant nibbling tendencies!! **Just kidding!** But, be careful!

    1. Sherry,
      Not sure, but I think the shade got them. They did fine the first few years, but got progressively got thinner as the large oak tree in my neighbor’s yard over shadowed my yard. At this point, I am without hope since now my yard is in deep shade nearly all of the day (except in winter).

      1. Without hope–that sounds pretty bleak. You’ve given me some ideas for blogging about shade, because many gardens are shady. In our climate, with global warming, shade is absolutely a plus. So I will try to come up with some shade garden suggestions in future blogs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s